Citeseerx impact of cmmibased process maturity levels on. Steve mcconnell on diseconomies of scale in software development. Citeseerx impact of cmmibased process maturity levels. Diseconomies of scale in software development let us assume that the size of a project is measured in lines of code loc. I think writing software has considerable diseconomies of scale. For example, assume that labor costs at a factory are constant as long as the factory produces between 100,000 and 500,000 units per month. Diseconomies definition of diseconomies by the free dictionary. Since software development effort can be greatly affected by the organizational process maturity level, this study examines the impact of different cmmibased process maturity levels on effort, productivity development team and diseconomy of scale for a standard project sizes.
One very important aspect of software economics as represented within todays software cost models is that the relationship between effort and size see the equation above exhibits. Adding software engineers to a project increases the number of conversations necessary between pairs of individuals. The reason this is important in addressing the diseconomy of scale is that pure scripting is still a perdevice task. With this principle, rather than experiencing continued decreasing. We present a new framework for solving optimization problems with a diseconomy of scale. The marginal cost of serving one additional copy of software in the old software as a. Project size is easily the most significant determinant of effort, cost and schedule for a software project. Letus assume that the size of a project is measured in lines of code loc. We define a novel linear programming relaxation for.
The concept of diseconomies of scale is the opposite of economies of scale. In other words, its a point in the production process where economies of scale reach their limit and start marginal costs begin to increase instead of decrease with additional production. Diseconomies definition of diseconomies by the free. A diseconomy of scale is realized when a the average cost per unit decreases as the facilitys size increases b it becomes cheaper to produce fewer items per production period c average. That is, diseconomies of scale occur when a company increases its output for a product.
T he additional costs of becoming too large are called diseconomies of. Microsoft economies and diseconomies of scale erinwhitehouse. But its still manually invoked, and requires people to drive the process. A software development manager will often need to make decisions about the allocation of resources across a number of different development projects. We met economies of scale and its opposite, diseconomies of. Economies and diseconomies of scale in software development. Diseconomies of scaleeconomic theory predicts that a firm may become less efficient if it becomes too large. Will a particular project remain on schedule, despite a headcount reduction of 50%, if the size of the next deliverable is reduced also by 50%. However, there is no consensus as to whether, in general, economies or diseconomies exist with respect to project size. Jun 20, 2018 the surprising truth about digital transformation. Software development works best in small batch sizes. Diseconomies of scale the decrease of efficiency in the making of a product by producing more of it. The following can be the factors causing external diseconomies of scale. Dec 18, 2014 we present a new framework for solving optimization problems with a diseconomy of scale.
An economy of scale situation that exists when larger scale lowers average cost. An economy of scale arises when an increase in output reduces average costs. None of the factors that contribute to software s diseconomy of scale is in the top half of factors in terms of significance. When a factory increases output, a reduction in the average. Jul 04, 2016 in my opinion the whole idea is a little flawed. Then, because software has close to zero of marginal cost the design cost is all the one we end up paying. Don reinertsen has some figures on batch size the principles of product development flow which also support the diseconomies.
Diseconomies of scale in software development jesus gil. Economies of scale are cost reductions that occur when companies increase production. Alex3917 on dec 15, 2015 for what its worth, the actual term for this is the marginal product of labor. Interpretation problems related to the use of regression. Unfortunately, despite the title, this paper focused on. Study 30 terms operations chapter 6 flashcards quizlet. Kitchenham s estimated the loglinear model in equation 1 above and found that the coefficient estimate of 31 was not significantly different from one at the ol 0. In such problems, our goal is to minimize the cost of resources used to perform a. Sometimes the company can negotiate to lower its variable costs as well. External diseconomies consist of factors which a company cant control, and it might not only affect the company, but it will affect the whole industry. Could you at least find a citation, however credible, that unionization actually lowers productivity on the larger scale.
There are more layers in the hierarchy that can distort a message and wider spans. Kitchenham s estimated the loglinear model in equation 1 above and found that the coefficient estimate. Software development has diseconomies of scale hacker news. As the business expands communicating between different departments and along the chain of command becomes more difficult. Reallife examples of diseconomies of scale include managerial challenges and wasted inventory.
Introduction developing software to meet functional requirement with acceptable quality, on planned schedule, and within budget is a target pursued by every software. May 20, 2019 economies of scale is the cost advantage that arises with increased output of a product. Diseconomy of scale definition of diseconomy of scale by. Diseconomies of scale are the features that lead to an increase in average costs as a business grows beyond a certain size. The process of counting function points, gathering data, analyzing data is commonly. Section 2 examines ten software development data sets and finds several instances of interpretation problems, e. Unfortunately, despite the title, this paper focused on constructing a model for effort and value in software development than drawing conclusions about economies and diseconomies. Ok, there are a few places where software development does exhibit economies of scale but on most occasions diseconomies of scale are the norm. Unfortunately, despite the title, this paper focused on constructing a model. Diseconomies of scale expresses the opposite of economies of scale. The additional costs of becoming too large are called diseconomies of scale. Another academic paper is economies and diseconomies of scale in software development by comstock, jiang, and davies. In this case, the decision to stick with too many erp systems can cause a business to ignore a growing back office that is creating workarounds and spending inordinate amounts of time maintaining old instances of legacy erps. Diseconomies of scale occur when longrun average costs start to rise with increased output.
Diseconomies of scale represent the situation where the marginal cost of a product increases as the output increases. In this case, the decision to stick with too many erp. People naturally assume that a system that is 10 times as large as another system will require something like 10 times as much effort to build. Many research studies report an economy of scale in software development, i. F5 this is the fourth blog in a series on the challenges arising from digital transformation. It takes place when economies of scale no longer function for a firm. Diseconomies of scale occur for several reasons, but all as a result of the difficulties of managing a larger workforce. The fixed costs, like administration, are spread over more units of production. Imagine the same milk that the author is talking about, imagine to design the system that get the milk from the cow to 2 people every morning. Having a script makes a five minute chore a five second task. Economy of scale, in economics, the relationship between the size of a plant or industry and the lowest possible cost of a product. In doing this, the manager will need to consider economies, or diseconomies, of scale.
Impact of cmmibased process maturity levels on effort. Software has diseconomies of scale not economies of scale. Nov 19, 2019 diseconomies of scale occur when a business outgrows existing infrastructure and systems. In fact, 4 of the 5 leastinfluential factors are scaling factors. Solving optimization problems with diseconomies of scale. Jul 17, 2006 17 jul 2006 diseconomies of scale and lines of code. Pdf evidence on economies of scale in software development. Software economics helps software managers allocate those resources in the most efficient manner. Is not software that has diseconomies of scale, is the design process. Diseconomies of scale is an economic concept referring to a situation in which economies of scale no longer functions for a firm. But the effort for a 1,000,000 loc system is more than 10 times as large as the effort for a 100,000 loc system. That is, diseconomies of scale occur when a company increases its output for a product such that it increases the cost per unit of the product. At this scale, it will encounter either limits on its ability to produce or the need to invest in new equipment.
Contrary to most manufacturing processes, the more software you build, the more expensive it is per unit item. Since software development effort can be greatly affected by the organizational process maturity level, this study examines the impact of different cmmibased process maturity levels on effort. Governments, nonprofits, and even individuals can also benefit from economies of scale. An important source of diseconomies is managerial in natureorganizing a large, complex enterprise is a challenge, and larger organizations tend to devote a larger percentage of their revenues to management of the operation. In microeconomics, diseconomies of scale are the cost disadvantages that economic actors accrue due to an increase in organizational size or on output, resulting in production of goods and services at increased perunit costs. Talking about actual economies of scale, software has massive economies of scale. It is contrary to the theory of economies of scale, which lays. Alex3917 on dec 15, 2015 for what its worth, the actual term for this is. Cmmi, process maturity, cocomo ii, effort multipliers, scale factors, diseconomy of scale, productivity rate. Sep 11, 2012 the theory of economies of scale is the cost benefits of expanding production within a company, or maybe even through the expansion of the market itself.
At this scale, it will encounter either limits on its ability to produce or the need to. Economic theory predicts that a firm may become less efficient if it becomes too large. Diseconomies of scale economics online economics online. Diseconomy of scale financial definition of diseconomy of scale. Of course, this phase of analysis and revamping in itself can be, and usually is, a diseconomy leading to hiring of new personnel and investment in new, competing systems. The theory of economies of scale is the cost benefits of expanding production within a company, or maybe even through the expansion of the market itself. Diseconomies of scale happen when a company or business grows so large that the costs per unit increase. The remaining part of the paper is organized as follows. Diseconomy of scale financial definition of diseconomy of. Evidence on economies of scale in software development. One very important aspect of software economics as represented within todays software cost models is that the relationship between effort and size see the equation above exhibits a diseconomy of scale. Economies of scale is the cost advantage that arises with increased output of a product. Diseconomies of scale and lines of code coding horror. Don reinertsen has some figures on batch size the principles of product development flow which also support the diseconomies of scale argument.
In his influential 1975 book the mythical manmonth, ibm software manager fred books describes a particularly severe diseconomy of scale. The software development diseconomy of scale is a result of the process exponent in the equation being greater than 1. This type of diseconomies rises with the increase in the production of a company beyond a certain level. Diseconomies of scale result in rising long run average costs which are experienced when a firm expands beyond its optimum scale, at q. The cost of resources grows superlinearly, as xq, with the amount x of resources used. Diseconomies of scale is a rare condition in large business when the average cost of producing one unit of material increases. None of the factors that contribute to softwares diseconomy of scale is in the. One important aspect of software economics is that the relationship between effort and size exhibits a diseconomy of scale. In such problems, our goal is to minimize the cost of resources used to perform a certain task. Economies of scale and scope social sci libretexts. Economies and diseconomies of scalegains and losses in productivity arising from increases in project sizeare of considerable, practical importance in software engineering. Diseconomy definition of diseconomy by the free dictionary.
The best programmers are typically 510 times more productive than the average ones. It means that above a certain size of the organization the savings of quantity production will be. Nothing unique to software here, and diseconomies of scale are a failure of software design, not an inherent property. Diseconomy of scale definition is an increase in unit costs brought about especially by increased size of production facilities usually used in plural. Economies of scale arise because of the inverse relationship between the quantity produced and perunit. Economies of scale arise because of the inverse relationship between the quantity. Software has diseconomies of scale, not economies of scale. Software has diseconomies of scale not economies of scale practical men, who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual influence, are usually the slaves of some defunct economist. An economy of scalethat larger scale lowers costarises when an increase in output reduces average costs. Cocomo ii factors with diseconomy of scale factors highlighted in blue. Diseconomies of scale is a phenomenon that occurs in large corporations, government organizations and public administration where adverse effects arise from large scale of the organization, which cause an increase in costs, such as communication problems, duplication of processes, internal tensions and.
677 845 315 515 773 1283 1234 1018 443 1504 345 272 804 1029 338 1014 1331 1180 816 1473 1468 1303 277 1014 434 288 1255 777 534 198 1459 373 69 641